For Sale: A Rare Private Island in the Florida Keys

Pretty Joe Rock, a private Island off Marathon Key.
Pretty Joe Rock is for sale at a paltry $2.5 million dollars

Marathon Key, Fla. – Do you have a little extra cash sitting around? You too can own a private island.

In an offering that captures the essence of luxury and exclusivity, Pretty Joe Rock, a .25 acre private island in the Florida Keys, has been listed for sale at $2.5 million. Known to locals as Sea Shell Key, this rare gem is situated at 1 Pretty Joe Rock in Marathon, Florida, and presents a unique opportunity for those dreaming of island life.

Out of the approximately 1,700 islands in the Florida Keys, only 34 offshore properties feature houses on them, and only nine islands have only one house. This exclusivity offers a blend of privacy and bespoke living, set against the stunning backdrop of the Gulf of Mexico.

The island’s real estate listing by Private Islands Inc. paints a picture of a dreamy escape: “Set just offshore from 43rd Street in the city of Marathon, Pretty Joe Rock offers an exceptional opportunity to make a Florida Key your own, as a private sanctuary with a home of your dreams, or as a successful vacation rental as the island has already been in the past.” The listing tantalizes potential buyers with the promise of spectacular views and mesmerizing sunsets, emphasizing the island’s potential both as a private retreat and a profitable rental property.

Brush with fame

Previously featured on HGTV’s “Buying the Beach” in 2014, Pretty Joe Rock has a history of capturing the imagination. However, the original home on the island was destroyed by Hurricane Irma in 2017, paving the way for new developments. The new owners will have the privilege of constructing a residence up to 4,000 square feet, offering ample space for a luxurious abode.

A unique aspect of Pretty Joe Rock is its connection to shore electricity and city water, a rarity for offshore islands, enhancing its appeal for modern living. Additionally, the property includes access to a private dock, ensuring convenient transportation to and from the mainland.

The allure of owning a private island, especially in a coveted location like the Florida Keys, is undeniable. Pretty Joe Rock represents not just a real estate investment, but a lifestyle choice for those who seek solitude, luxury, and an intimate connection with nature. As such, this listing is not just a transaction, but an invitation to own a piece of paradise.

Author